This is BX @ Boxden.com


Mar 4 - Is Putin a Psychopath, or Does He Just Play One on TV?


 Mar 4 - Is Putin a Psychopath, or Does He Just Play One on TV?
topic by Machiavelli - 03-04-2014, 07:37 PM - Boxden > Non-headline articles, author commentary, documentaries, and more


The consensus opinion after Putin’s press conference earlier today is that he has lost his mind. It was rambling, angry, discursive, and at times just bizarre.

Of course all of the usual Putinisms were there. Most notably, blaming the West for everything in a stream of whataboutism. This was accented by claims that the Ukrainian opposition consists mainly of thugs and fascists; that Yanukovych was wrongly ousted and didn’t order any violence against protestors; and that the opposition was very well trained and professional, having passed through training camps in the Baltics and Poland. (Take this as a very ominous warning, people.)

My dear colleague, look how well trained the people who operated in Kiev were. As we all know they were trained at special bases in neighbouring states: in Lithuania, Poland and in Ukraine itself too. They were trained by instructors for extended periods. They were divided into dozens and hundreds, their actions were coordinated, they had good communication systems. It was all like clockwork. Did you see them in action? They looked very professional, like special forces. Why do you think those in Crimea should be any worse?

Yes. Those evil Poles and Lithuanians, training crack troops to throw rocks and fashion catapults. Definitely far more lethal than camouflaged masked men toting AKs.

More broadly, Russia and Putin are always right: the West is always hypocritical and wrong.

Putin also denied the obvious, claiming that there are no Russian troops in Crimea, just local “self-defense forces” which he denies were trained by Russia.

In other words, there is no agreement on the basic facts of the situation, meaning that any attempt at negotiation with him, either by the Ukrainian government or the West, is doomed to failure. He rejects the legitimacy of the protests, views the outcome as a fascist coup arranged by the West, and denies that Russia is directly involved in the occupation of Crimea.

These were the substantive elements of insanity (paranoia, specifically) of the conference. But Putin added various asides that illustrated a man that feels no need to self-censor, but is so convinced of his own brilliance that anything that crosses his mind should be shared with the world. These “thoughts” were truly bizarre and mendacious, and even more suggestive of madness.

For instance, when discussing the alleged self-defense forces in Crimea, Putin claimed they were just kitted out in store-bought gear:

QUESTION: Mr President, a clarification if I may. The people who were blocking the Ukrainian Army units in Crimea were wearing uniforms that strongly resembled the Russian Army uniform. Were those Russian soldiers, Russian military?

VLADIMIR PUTIN: Why don’t you take a look at the post-Soviet states. There are many uniforms there that are similar. You can go to a store and buy any kind of uniform.

They must have some awesome Army-Navy stores in the FSU: not only can you get up to date cammo, you can also pick up the latest AKs and military trucks.

Then he went on to criticize the massive corruption and social stratification in Ukraine, but denied there was anything comparable in Russia:

Corruption has reached dimensions that are unheard of here in Russia. Accumulation of wealth and social stratification – problems that are also acute in this country – are much worse in Ukraine, radically worse. Out there, they are beyond anything we can imagine imagination. Generally, people wanted change, but one should not support illegal change.

Words fail.

In the same breath, he gave a Ukrainian history lesson:

In my opinion, this revolutionary situation has been brewing for a long time, since the first days of Ukraine’s independence. The ordinary Ukrainian citizen, the ordinary guy suffered during the rule of Nicholas II, during the reign of Kuchma, and Yushchenko, and Yanukovych.

Ordinary Ukrainians guys suffered under Nicholas II, Kuchma, Yushchenko, Yanukovich. Anybody notice a name missing from that list? Stalin, maybe? (Lenin should get honorable mention too.) The guy who k!lled one-third of the Ukrainian population via starvation and executions, a total of around 3-8 million people? Think there was a little suffering in 1932-1933? As bad as Yanukovych was, his total body count during the uprising is on the order of the body count every 6 minutes at the height of the Holmodor.

This omission is particularly di$gusting given the immense psychological toll that the Holmodor took and continues to take on Ukrainians. Don’t think that the omission will not resonate deeply in Ukraine. It is a taunting reminder of how Russians deny, deny, deny the Holmodor, and get incensed-hysterical, actually-at any moral claim made against them by Ukrainians.

The impression of insanity is only reinforced by other actions during the past several days, including a live fire exercise in the Baltic (witnessed by Putin) and today’s launch of an ICBM test. Put it altogether, and Putin gives the impression of approaching Kim Jung Un or Kim Jung Il levels of aggressive craziness. (And for those who say these exercises and tests were planned in advance, they could have easily been canceled if Putin wanted to lower the tension level. The fact he let them proceed tells you all you need to know about his intent and mindset.)

So what are the broader implications of his disturbing display of mental imbalance? No doubt the Europeans are even more intimidated now, and will be all the more reluctant to challenge a leader with a nuclear arsenal that they view as mad.

And that raises another possibility: that Putin was playing the psycho for effect. The Slavic version of Nixon’s Madman Theory, and which Machiavelli wrote about centuries earlier: he wrote that leaders can find it “a very wise thing to simulate madness.”

I will say, watching the video, that Putin did a very, very credible impression of a madman, but that’s necessary to make the gambit work, isn’t it?

I don’t know whether he’s truly mad, or merely feigning it, but the effect will likely be the same. The disturbing display of mental imbalance will work to his favor, and lead the Europeans in particular to back away slowly, letting him keep his current conquests, and prepare for his next move. He may back off now, but he will be back for more. And quite possibly not just in Ukraine. But in the Baltic states and Poland.
Streetwise Professor » Is Putin a Psychopath, or Does He Just Play One on TV?


share this topic »   Share this on Twitter Share this on Facebook

5 comments for "Mar 4 - Is Putin a Psychopath, or Does He Just Play One on TV?"


 03-05-2014, 12:34 PMaway - #2
Deuterion 1 heat pts

  d 
space
$2,824 | POWERFUL
This article is just mindless western propaganda. For one, the US is just as corrupt, if not more corrupt than Russia. Secondly, Russia hasn't spilled any blood in Ukraine. Thirdly, Russia had a treaty with Ukraine where they could have up to 25k soldiers in Crimea up til 2047 I believe. Lastly, anyone who says that Svoboda isn't a Neo-Nazi organization is either lying or misinformed.
 03-05-2014, 02:15 PMaway - #3
PoetikTrev 7 heat pts

  d 
space
$4,430 | 14730749
Ukraine and the 'Little Cold War' | Stratfor
 03-11-2014, 09:32 PMaway - #4
IAmABeast 

  d 
space
$811 | 1018779
what kind of a idiot wrote this propaganda. #### ####
 
 


Go Back   Boxden.Com - Stay First. Follow BX. > BX Table Of Contents > BX Daily Bugle - news and headlines > Non-headline articles, author commentary, documentaries, and more
    
         

 



Latest hot topics on fire the past 48 hrs
Image inside  Xbox One Games Store New Releases 9/02/14
64 comments
NFL JJ Watt earns a 6 year-$100 Million Dollar extension wit..
51 comments
NBA Remember back when Boston was projected to beat Miami in..
66 comments
 Video inside Kevin Gates Real Talk On The Breakfast Club: Prison Li...
New reply 1 minute ago - 97 comments - by BreakfastClub
 Video inside This Just In: Hitman Holla Was In A Bad Car Accident
New reply 4 minutes ago - 108 comments - by Guvnor
 Image(s) inside The Real 50 Cent Junior Celebrates His 2nd Birthday
New reply 2 minutes ago - 71 comments - by Mutant Boy
 Video inside Snoop Dogg Responds To Star (shots Fired)
New reply 7 minutes ago - 130 comments - by bkid
  Pc: Star Citizen Arena Commander Demo (free Download 1...
New reply 3 minutes ago - 63 comments - by mainevent4u88
  Sep 1 - Exclusive: Man Who Leaked All Jennifer Lawren...
New reply 7 minutes ago - 60 comments - by messy marv stan
 NBA Kobe Bryant The Greatest Offensive Player Ever?
New reply 4 minutes ago - 102 comments - by TheeMrMarvel
 Image(s) inside Apparently Dude "tried" To Snatch Quavo (mig...
New reply 7 minutes ago - 222 comments - by Just Jimmy

Like BX on Facebook Follow BX on Twitter
5,766 fans of BX | none new today 4,746 following | none new today

hot topic blog   »    hip-hop   |   sports   |   movies   |   games   |   news   |   wild'ish   |   gear   |   rides   |   tech

contact us   |   mobile   |   privacy statement

© Boxden.com. 1998 - end of time.