Amani Toomer : "Tony Romo is better than Eli Manning."

You have to put Eli ahead of Romo based on success...

BUT, people overrate the hell out of Eli because of those rings. I guess that's just how things go [pic]

If you really watch all the games, you'd see that the two aren't that far apart.

If Romo, Rivers, etc. win a ring...all the sudden they're top 5, but people laugh at you if you say that now.

Antonio Romero has top 5 talent, especially as of late; every QB has to have a maturation process and I think Romo has approached that level. Both QBs are under a lot of pressure every year. (New York, and being the Cowboys QB) Romo is more talented, (stronger arm, more accurate.. and no one over thrown to Austin and one amazing sideline pass to Manningham doesn't make Eli more accurate [pic], Romo is 10x more mobile) Both make about the same decisions at this point.

I'd Say Romo is more confident in his abilities, which is why he makes errors. (6 fumbles in 6 playoff games :lebronthatsn@sty:

But if you put Romo with that pass rush he'd get atleast one title as well..

Remember earlier last year Romo had a lead in the 4th against the Pats, Brady just had a drive because overthinkin[..] Garrett ran 3 consecutive times (including 3rd & 7) [pic]

Romo is better(QBR,4th Qtr QBR i.e. all the stats niccas were suckin Eli off last year) .. Eli has more wins(rings) therefore Eli is better by default.. I mean that is how it works right? [pic]

If this, if that, this hypothetical setup, blah blah blah...at the end of the day it is what it is. You can sit back and do this with all players, play the if game. You can say what you want about regular season stats but WE ALL KNOW that the post-season is a whole different monster.

Romo won 1 post-season game. Just one!!! Thats where greatness is defined and Eli has gone all the way twice, which means he had to grind through the second twice. Romo has never had to face that grind. So lets look at the whole picture instead of just stats, stats can be misleading as hell

Out of that entire post all you pulled out was if Romo had Eli's pass rush he'd have one ring..

You're a !!ing moron.

That "post season is a different monster" talk is bull!!, you haven't played a regular season game to even make a statement on what it's like in the playoffs; stfu ho.. it's the same as anyother game.
cue Herm Edwards.. YOU PLAY TO WIN THE !!ING GAME. Period. Just because something worth more than a regular season game is at stake doesn't mean you play that much more harder, if you aren't giving the same amount of effort in week one as you are in the SB you don't need to be playing in the first place.

Romo made the playoffs 3 times and won 1 game.. [pic] you act as if dude made the playoffs 6 consecutive years.

and that 1 win he was 23-35 65.7 244 2TD 0 INT

You have to admit, when he is good he's top 3 or 4 in the league. Every QB !!s up, see SB where Brady has the intentional grounding call on the first drive.. "bbbb But He probably didn't know because it rarely happens... Romo does that and yall down dude throat.

No one QB is god..

Elite the GAAAWD made the playoffs 5 times... 3 of which he was one and done like Romo.

Let's not sit here and pretend dude takes his team deep into the playoffs ALLLLL the time without the help of his defense..

in fact most successful QBs are doing it with their Defense..

outside of Romo, Rodgers, and Brees(even though his defense had the most takeaways the year they won.)

looks at the superbowl contenders for the past 10 years.

Steelers, Patriots(pre spygate), the !!ing bears with Grossman,tampa bay,and the Ravens with Dilfer.. rarely do you get a SB winning QB who basically did it on his own.

In fact it was only Rogers, Brees, and Peyton.

[pic]

Eli overrated..

Still hurts [pic]