Mlb 2k7 -or- Mlb The Show

[JAYMETRO]

Have Played Both (i Own The Show)....just Wanted To Know Ya Opinions.....

Mlb2k7 Has Better Commentary, Better Pitch Control And Thats About It ...discuss

[Will Branson]

this is a good topic.....

i have mlb 2k7 and i like it its pretty good.... but i have also played the show on ps2 and that game was also pretty good

im still trying to think if i should sell my mlb 2k7 and get the show or should i just keep mlb 2k7 and forget about the show?

i just want to see which game is better overall

if i had to pick though, i would say the show was better just because of that point of view thing where you just play as the player that you created

but i also want to see other peoples opinon?

if i end up selling mlb 2k7 i will probably sell it for like $30 so if anyones interested let me know

[Chuck_Remixed]

I well playing both for a while now, MLB 2k7 is better. Talking bout the next gen versions. Me and my brother play MLB 2k7 way more now on my 360 and play The Show every once and a while.

[darealness818]

its really hard to decide this year.....its not as obvious as choosing between nba 2k7 n a sh*tty game like nba live 07 cuz both baseball games are actually good.......

like mah man said before 2k7 has da best commentary but the show has better presentation....2k7 also has better pitching but i think the fielding in the show is better

dis year im playin the show more cuz last year i played da shyt out of 2k6 and 2k7 is no different than 2k6

[kegar89]

Haven't played The Show yet but MLB 2K7 within itself is an amazing game.

[JAYMETRO]

PROS AND CONS OF BOTH GAMES (IMO)

-2K7 THE FIELD FEELS SO SMALL, IN ANY STADIUM,PLUS ITS SO EASY (AND I MEAN EASY) TO ROB THE OPPSING TEAM OF BIG PLAYS WHICH TAKES AWAY FROM THE REALISM N EXCITEMENT..

2K7 HAS BETTER GRAPHICS THO...(MINUS THE CROWD, THEY LOOK SO sh*tTY)

THE SHOW HAS A BETTER FEEL TO IT, MORE X-CITEMENT, BETTER CROWDS, BIGGER FIELD, MORE REALISM OVERALL

BUT, THE COMMERTARY IS fu*kING HORRILBE, THEY SOUND LIKE TEENAGERS WITH THERE SMART ASS REMARKS...LIKE IF UR IN EXTRA INNINGS, ONE OF THEM WILL ACTUALLY SAY " CMON, THEY DONT PAY US OVERTIME FOR THIS GUYS, SOMEONE WIN ALREADY".......I MEAN WTF IS THAT ALL ABOUT???

[Dimone293]

I own both.....prob going to sell 2k7 on ebay. The Show for ps3 IMO is the best baseball game every made.....

[Will Branson]

I own both.....prob going to sell 2k7 on ebay. The Show for ps3 IMO is the best baseball game every made.....


lol.... samething i will probably end up doing as well... i want to try out the show on ps3 because it was pretty good on ps2

[jhicks]

I think the show way better,2K7 seeme like everything is a homerun or a hit to the wall and you can rob almost anything climbing up the wall.anytime carlos lee has his shins at the wall,its ridiculous. most games i play the score is ridiculous, a damn nfl score 18-15 or sometimes more with schilling and glavine pitching.

[Will Branson]

lol... yeah i use the mets on 2k7 and the score is usually pretty high like atleast 10... lol and there is alot of homeruns and close calls to the wall...

[BayLoc]

havent played 2k7, but cant stop playin the show on my psp or ps3, and i fu*kin hate baseball, but this game is ill

[e_dubble]

Have'nt played the show, (I don't have a PS3 or PS2), but I love 2K7, but everybody is right it's way too easy, I had to turn up the difficulty hella times
and my A's have 4 guys with over 50 home runs in like 50 games, have'nt even reached the all star break and Eric C:smh: havez has hit 5 homers in a game twice.:smh:

[JAYMETRO]

^^^^^^